Responses to The Lancet "Gaza Letter"
On July 23, 2014, a number of NGO doctor-activists, including Mads Gilbert (NORWAC), Swee Ang (Medical Aid for Palestinians), and Paola Manduca (New Weapons Committee), published An Open Letter for the People in Gaza in The Lancet, a UK medical journal. Under the guise of presenting “the facts,” they demonize Israel for “the perversity of a propaganda that justifies the creation of an emergency to masquerade a massacre.” In response, the Israeli Ministry of Health reportedly identified the letter as “bordering on blood libel.”
Responses to the Lancet letter:
To the misled doctors, pseudoscientists and 9/11 supporters in Gaza, Hillel S. Maresky, The Times of Israel, July 27, 2014
An Open Letter for the Readers of the Lancet, Prof. Zvi Ram, July 2014
Open Letter for the people in Gaza- more than a military conflict, Nathan M. Stall, Philip B. Berger, Joel G. Ray, Tali Bogler, Chaim M. Bell, on behalf of 1,234 Canadian physicians, The Lancet, July 30, 2014
Our First Submission to The Lancet. From a Bomb Shelter., Tamir Wolf, Danny Hava Brown, Shachar Moshe Aharony, July 30, 2014 Also see here.
Dr. Edgar Pick´s Letter to The Lancet Editor Richard Horton, July 28, 2014
Editor Richard Horton´s Response to Dr. Edgar Pick, July 28, 2014
Dr. Edgar Pick Responds to Editor Richard Horton, July 29, 2014
Prof. Michael Vanyukov Letter to Richard Horton, July 31, 2014
Israel advocates get little space to respond to epistle in ´The Lancet´, The Jerusalem Post, July 31, 2014
Robert Roth Letter to the Editor of the Lancet, Robert P. Roth JD, on behalf of Maimonides Society of Metro Detroit (representing more than 800 physicians), July, 2014
Israel-Gaza conflict correspondence, Jeremy M. Levin and Ron Cohen, August 4, 2014
Israel-Gaza conflict correspondence, Adi Leiba, Moshe Pinkert, Yitshak Kreiss, The Lancet, August 5, 2014
Israel-Gaza conflict correspondence, Jeffery J. Goldberger, Richard L Popp, Douglas P. Zipes, on behalf of 43 signatories, The Lancet, August 6, 2014
Israel-Gaza conflict correspondence, Yoram Blachar, August 11, 2014