In a July 27th BBC News article, Steve Crawshaw, spokesman for Human Rights Watch, offers harsh criticism of the new Human Rights Council (HRC), based in Geneva and established one year ago to replace the UN Human Rights Commission: "I think it would be crazy to say that it has not been a disappointing year...The HRC should have been, if you like, a beacon of human rightsWe really hoped that the new council would move things forward radically. It has, to be honest, failed to do so," states Crawshaw. The article goes on to note that "critics say the council is barely any improvement on its predecessor ? and now there are moves in the US congress to try to cut off funding." Later in the article, Kristen Silverberg, the US assistant secretary of state responsible for US policy, highlights the Council's singling out of Israel: "It's really been a grave disappointment to usThis is a council that devoted eight different actions to bashing and criticising Israel before it lifted a finger to help people in any other part of the world, including the long-suffering people of Burma, or North Korea, or Zimbabwe."